Thursday, December 6, 2007

No Smoking Uncovered

I watched the movie two times. Like most other people, my first reaction to the movie was - "What?"

But in the second time I realised Anurag Kashyap is on a totally different level than the Indian audience. And this post is dedicated to him.

No Smoking is a mystery, a movie open to interpretations of all sorts. Here I present mine, a very specific one. This is not a review; this is an interpretation of the movie. I assume that you have already seen the movie.

Warning : This article contains tons of spoilers! Do not read if you have not watched the movie. It won't make any sense to you if you haven't watched the movie. And if you watch the movie after reading this, you won't have any fun.

First things first, this movie is not about how smoking can be injurious to health, or why you should quit smoking. It is about lusts in life, how freedom of choice is curbed, and how you pay for your sins. The climax is, in my opinion, pessimistic. This may upset some of the general Indian crowd (used to watch Karan Johar crap).

K's Siberian Dream - Not a dream, actually a vision. K is fed up with life, the only two things he is hanging on to is cigarettes and his own life. He wishes to escape from his current surroundings, so his soul takes him away. But even in such a remote place, K cannot leave his only lust in life - smoking. It signifies his longing, his desire to be free from the nagging and pressures of the society.

The Bathtub - Everybody has a portal for the movement of their ideas, their souls. K's portal is his bathtub. It is his relaxing place, and when he is in his bathtub, he ponders upon his life and usually ends up dreaming. His bathtub serves as a gateway to his soul's escape, and hence the bathtub is present in his dream too, in Siberia.

Baba Bangali - He is the incarnation of God on Earth. By using various unique methods, his only wish is to free people of their lusts, and to purify their souls. He can go to any extent, without any respect for people's personal choice or freedom. He can be seen as God's Big Brother on Earth.

1 Rupee in Cash - It tells us how we tend to neglect small things, and do not pay attention to things which are not of much value. The 1 rupee was a fee to save K's soul, his soul could use the 1 rupee to reach to his body, and escape the punishment. In a way, it is a way of showing that small things can purify your soul of all your sins.

The Carpet - The Carpet is not a tracking device! For heaven's sake! It was just the carpet that cost K 21 lakh rupees. The Prayogshala was masked as Kolkatta Karpets.

Anjali/Annie - Another way of escaping. Anjali is K's wife, in reality (if K is assumed to be real, that is). Anjali is a nagger, another person who wants to curb K's freedom, wants him to quit smoking. She uses all the weapons she can to get him to quit smoking - blackmail, emotional drama, insulting him and hurting his ego. All this makes him imagine Annie, who looks exactly like his wife, but is a sweet and understanding person, and most importantly - She does not want K to quit smoking. K's brain is so stressed out, he doesn't seem to notice that Annie and Anjali have the same face.

Cigarette Shastra - Sent by Baba Bangali, it is a rule book, a Bible or any holy book you want to call it. The most interesting part is the zero minute. It was put there to tempt the people (under the programme) to sin, reinforcing the idea that it is God's creations which force you to sin, and it is God who punishes you for sinning.

Soul Bath - When you have sinned, your soul becomes polluted, so it has to be 'cleaned'. Remember Baba saying, "Aatma hai to shareer ishwar hai, aatma nahi to nashwar hai.....Agar mann kamzor hai to aatma ko jhaad phoonk kar mukt karna padta hai"? This was what he meant. K failed to recognise and rectify his sins, so his soul was separated from his body, to be punished and purified. The bath was to cleanse his soul.


I wouldn't say that the movie was theist, but it definitely fuels the idea of existence of an all powerful being, existence of rules, sinning and punishment, hell.


From Anurag Kashyap's blog -

K’s arrogance is the obvious arrogance, that everyone sees everyday.. he smokes..he breathes nicotine.. he says no one tells me what to do.. i breathe cinema.. and forever everyone has been telling me not to make the kind of cinema i do.. NO SMOKING is a tale of an arrogant man and another who is much more arrogant, who lives in his world, where he controls everything and he thinks he is morally superior to anyexisting Homo sapiens, he is the kind of man who thrives on minorities and underpriveleged, he worships the dictatorian attitude and all he wants from you is to lose your soul and convert….it,s a tale about an arrogant man’s descent into morality.. and the architecture of the moral world is so absurd that it sometimes beats reality.. what happens in the film is a parallel to what happens in the real world..

20 Puddles of puke:

meetu said...

Pretty cool analysis!

My take on baba bengali was that he was a representation of all people who claim to know how we should live our lives. The pragyogshala signifying all the self-improvement programs that are in vogue.

meetu said...

oops! didn't mean to puke over your post :)

Mahesh said...

Thanks for clearing up my doubts. I think I now understand the movie.

ellessdee said...

hi thanks for commenting to my no smoking review. but alas your simple statement that the movie can be uncovered to our feeble minds post reading your review smacks of condescencion. apporva everybody understands the allusions that anurag has splaterred through the film. all the theories, parallels, symbolism, unfortunately is so in your face that we lesser mortals all got that, but that doesn't make the film. a gentleman said, many years agon, method to the madness - sadly no smoking is a film too intelligent for its own good. descent into hell, despair, authority, revolt, assertion...mere adjectives and good to have in a deconstructive, structaralist, post modernist world. but its good that you saw, understood and enjoyed, anurag would be happy.

Akshay Gupta said...

The first Hindi film I was dying too see straight after I saw the trailers and read the reviews. I love movies with deep emotions and characters displaying brain thoughts and intensifying the scenes. I haven't seen this movie yet, hope to see it very soon.
If you liked this movie you are sure to like Requiem for a Dream, Being Cyrus, Sarkar(different but intense), Batman Begins ...

Wamiq said...

Muah Muah Muah Muah

U r the only person who seems to understand the movie whose interpretation i have read online...


i saw idiots comparin this to fight club, eternal sunshine etc...

if u have not seen any of these lynch movies please please download them soon...... they are similar having surreal imagery and abstract interpretation...
1.Lost Highway
2.Mulholland Drive (my fav)
3. Blue Velvet

Apoorv Khatreja said...

Now thanks for the comment Wamiq, but we don't want the MPAA coming and sueing me for illegally downloading movies from the Internet. So we'll stick to buying DVDs :D.

And Akshay, tell me your opinon about the movie after you watch it.

Anonymous said...

Well that was a good interpretation of the movie.

but i didnt get the answer for the fingers which is waht i am searching in the internet.

i couldnt find a logical explantion for the fingers in any of the reviews.

if not a logical explanation, at least an explantion will make it good.

Anonymous said...

wonderful and deep interpretation. was looking for this. thanks.

ShAkE Inc. said...
This post has been removed by the author.
ShAkE Inc. said...

Just to let you know,
The Prayogshala doesnt exist in reality! In fact its a metaphor for the rehab/hospital in the film. And Baba Bengali? Well, he is in fact the doctor! Quite commendable, the way such metaphors have been portrayed.
(If you look closely, *Baba Bengali is wearing the same red thread around his wrist that the doc is shown wearing in the end...*he is shown operating on a patient in his prayogshala...*he removes his gloves before he meets K for the first time...so on, so forth)

And yeah, those fingers are shown to be cut. But do not take it literally cuz its just the way the director wants to show how freedom can be curbed. Those two fingers which are shown to be 'cut' potray nothing but freedom (remember without them K cannot smoke or hold the pen to write, as in Abbas's case)

Seems like someone in Bollywood is going the Lynch way...Bravo Anurag, keep up the good work! Guess, Indian Cinema won't be the same again ;-)

ellessdee said...

thank god a film is generating so much of comment. but i have differed in the past and still do. has anybody here seen rahul awail's 'jo bole so nihaal' with sunny deol in it? the same film that got banned in punjab etc... well for people who are bought over by easy symbolism and metaphor chek this out...

its a motif repeated through out the film...whenever sunny sees a girl in the us of a his mother in some punjab village gets a flutter in hear heart. once when sunny is about to do the birds and bees thing with the heroine his mother gets up in punjab, shaking all over...his sexual act in us of a has a corresponding effect on his mother in punjab...incest, oedipus complex or should we call mr freud... no we don't need to because we are all under the influence of mr lynch and other such...regards

Count Sahaj said...

Wow.. man.. really good analysis..
almost sopt on...

the only thing tht i had trouble deciphring was the incident happend on the new years eve..

But i hav seen the movie only once.. guess will have to see it again..

Count Sahaj said...

Wow.. man.. really good analysis..
almost sopt on...

the only thing tht i had trouble deciphring was the incident happend on the new years eve..

But i hav seen the movie only once.. guess will have to see it again..

Ghurram said...

Baba Bengali -- more than relating him to God, you could probably equate him to Big Brother (1984, George Orwell). He is watching all of us ....

Anonymous said...

brilliant analysis

AP

Alvin said...

Awsome analogy on the film.

Thirumal said...

Awesome analysis man!
But u went in a different concept.yeah, i got it after u discribing the baba bangali's charecter.

Even u can check it out from director's view on this.It is completly the director's personal film.Its about people who r living or working or existing against their freedom.
Its a concious effort on behalf them who wanna live,think on their own way.like how Anurag getting problems from his hatred production companies,dumbed audience and the censor board.So baba bangali represents these people.
First let us cheer ourselves before cheering Anurag for getting this great film on Indian screen.

Once again i salute Anurag for his brave attempt.

Abhishek said...

hi,

I watched No Smoking recently on TV and went on for the search of the hidden meaning. As you rightly said the movie is open to interpretations. It has a promising begining but somewhere in the middle it loses the viewer. The collection of symbols like the dream, bathtub etc. as you have described is fantastic. However, if it could be made a little more close to reality it would have been a classic. As human being we are nothing but manifestation of greed, hatred and attachments. To describe this nature we don't need something which is divine i.e. baba bengali. It could have been made into a tremendous psy thriller but feels sad that they messed it up.

parth said...

nice analysis... movie is making some sense now.... but in one of the interviews Anurag Kshyap himself told that even he doesnt know what he has made in the movie....

what was the english movie which this was the remake of?